Name ____________________________

Combined Score is out of 100.  Maximum score is 152.


Part I: Getting The Web Server Working

Total score is out of 60.  Maximum score is 72.

Logistics (3 pts each)
___ Has compilation instructions
___ Compiles without modification
___ Allows for port specification
___ Starts without error, binds to correct port
___ Code is readable (commented & formatted)

Content Delivery (5 pts each)
___ Correctly delivers a text (html) file
___ Correctly deliver binary (gif/jpg) file
___ HTTP 1.0, connections are closed after file sent
___ HTTP 1.1, connections are kept open for some time, then closed
___ HTTP 1.1, timeout is refreshed after new request

Thread/Process Model (12 pts first, 5 pts each additional)
___ Implements spawning thread model (-.5 pts off if spawning process)
___ Implements pool thread/process model
___ Implements event driven model

Error Conditions (2 pts each)
___ Catches socket errors correctly
___ Reports error when file does not exit
___ Reports error when file has bad permissions
___ Reports error on malformed requests
___ Reports error when URL descends below root (using ../) (bonus)


Part I Total Score _____

Part II: Performance and Results

Total score is out of 40.  Maximum score is 80. (*)'d items are considered 
the "basic" assignment.  Must score more than 45 points in Part I to 
receive more than 40 points on Part II.

Client/Server (4 pts each)
___ (*) Client spawns multiple threads or processes
___ (*) Client supports HTTP 1.0 and 1.1
___ (*) Server supports HTTP 1.0 and 1.1

Methodology (4 pts each)
___ (*) Client(s) runs on a different machine than server
___ (*) Defines saturation and takes it into account
___ (*) Code instrumented to calculate connection and transmission time
___ (*) Describes evaluation environment

Graphs (how well each shows expected behavior, 5 pts each)
___ Latency vs. file size
___ (*) Throughput/Bandwidth vs. file size
___ Throughput/Bandwidth vs. time
-or- Others (Latency vs. Connection Rate, etc.)

Discussion
___ (*) How well the paper is written (7 pts)
___ Explains graphs in detail (5 pts)
___ Motivation/overview is provided (5 pts)
___ Discusses effect of thread model on performance (5 pts)
___ Discusses HTTP 1.0/1.1 for varying RTT (5 pts)
___ Discusses HTTP 1.0/1.1 for varying files sizes (5 pts)
___ Evaluates a real server for comparison (5 pts)


Part II Total Score _____


Overall Score _____